Reviews - XFX Core Edition 450W
Sample Provided by: XFX (By jonny on Thu, Mar-17-2011)

Page 4 - Scoring and conclusion

At jonnyGURU.com we grade on four criteria, each with their own weight that has an effect on the total score. Performance, functionality, value and aesthetics are all judged to calculate the final score.

Performance (40% of the final score): Let's start by accentuating the positive. This unit is 80 Plus Bronze, which is good, but not the best we've seen lately. The ripple and noise suppression was pretty good too. Can we eliminate the negative? No. The voltage regulation is all over the place with really high +12V voltages that just kept getting higher, including a +12V rail that was over spec when the non-primary rails were loaded to the maximum. I'm afraid I can only give this unit an 8.  I considered a lower grade, but the fact of the matter is the voltage stayed within the ATX specification... until I crossloaded it, of course.  But this isn't a realistic load.

Functionality (20% of the final score): The XFX Core Edition 450W is a fixed cable power supply. Since it's not modular or even semi-modular, it can't get a perfect score, but it does come in a very compact size and the packaging really does a good job of protecting the unit. For this, I give the unit a 9 in this category.

Value (30% of the final score): The price of this unit today is $54 at Newegg before any rebates or anything. That makes it about as inexpensive as any 450W power supply like it. Better power supplies can be had, but they tend to be $10 to $15 more. If the performance was better (no wacky voltage regulation), I would give this unit a 9.5 or 10 for value, but because Seasonic has changed something in the way this power supply functions when it was relabeled for XFX, I can only give it a 9.

Aesthetics (10% of the final score): The XFX Core Edition 450W has a basic look, no frills and comes in a compact size. The cables are all sleeved and basic colors are used. For this, I'm giving this power supply a 9.5.

Performance

8

Functionality

9

Value

9

Aesthetics

9.5

Total Score

8.5

The XFX Core Edition 450W is clearly a totally different animal from the 650W, 750W and 850W we reviewed recently. On the up side of things, the aesthetics are toned down which means we don't have the trim piece that adds 10mm to the depth of the unit. The lack of a second CPU power connector is addressed, although its less likely you would use a 450W PSU in a multi-CPU system. On the other hand, the higher wattage (650W and up) XFX Core Edition power supplies use a Seasonic platform that utilizes DC to DC and solid capacitors for the non-primary rails, while this 450W is based on the relatively old S12II platform. And if I could grade on excessive marketing fluff and incorrect information on the box, I'd drive the score into the ground, but over all it's not a horrible unit. I dare say it's an ok unit and with the occasional $10 rebate is hard to resist. But it's not a unit I can find myself personally recommending.

The Good:

  • Efficient
  • Small
  • Five year warranty 

The Bad:

  • Crazy +12V regulation that went up under load and even went out of spec when crossloaded 

The Mediocre:

  • Price is pretty decent.  It would feel like an even better price if the +12V wasn't wonky. 

Stay tuned tomorrow where we'll be doing a quick run down of this unit's slightly bigger brother: the Seasonic S12II based Core Edition 550W.



Discuss the XFX Core Edition 450W in our forums here.

 

JonnyGURU Feeds
Add our RSS feeds to your favorite RSS Reader or homepage.

JonnyGURU Reviews
AddThis Feed Button

JonnyGURU News
AddThis Feed Button

JonnyGURU Articles
AddThis Feed Button

JonnyGURU Forums
AddThis Feed Button

Follow us onFollow Us!
 
Site-Info | Affiliates | Contact Us | Site-Map
Copyright © 2012 - JonnyGURU.com