Welcome!         


Modders-Inc Reviews
·Cooler Master HAF X
·Cooler Master Storm Inferno Gaming Mouse
·NZXT Hades Mid Tower Computer Case
·Jetway NC63-330-LF Mini ITX Motherboard
·Asus EAH 5750 Formula 1GB GDDR5 Video Card
·ASUS Sabertooth 55i Motherboard Review
·NZXT Premium Cables
·CaseAppeal AV8 Custom Computer Case
·Jetway JNC96FL-510-LF Mini ITX
·ASUS Blu-ray BC-08B1ST Combo Internal Drive

read more...
Reviews - SilverStone Strider ST75F 750W
Sample Provided by: SilverStone (By jonny on Sat, Dec-02-2006)

( Reviews Main | Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4 | Printer Friendly )

Now that I know what connector goes to what label, I know how I'm going to set up the load tester.

For those who don't know how I go about testing power supplies; I use a SunMoon SM8800 power supply ATE (automated test equipment.) Essentially, it's a machine made specifically for the testing of ATX12V power supplies.  It can put up to 10 different static loads on up to 10 different rails at a time.  I can also ramp loads up and down and do short tests, etc. 

For the sake of a review, I just pre-program a few different loads into the tester and run each one for about a half an hour.  For the ST75F, I've programmed seven different loads ranging from 145.4W to 761.9W.  The seventh, and final test, is a crossload test with the +12V rails maxed out, and a minimal load on the 3.3V and 5V rails.

For more information about my testing methodology, read this.

So I plugged the 8-pin EPS+12V of the power supply into the 8-pin of the ATE for the +12V1 and +12V2 tests. Since the load on the 8-pin is split across two +12V rails, I pretty muched doubled up the load I put on that connector.

The +12V3 load is split up between the main ATX connector and one of the PCI-e connectors.  The +12V4 load is split up between the two PCI-e connectors plugged into the +12V4 interface of the ST75F.

Intake and exhaust temperatures are measured with a temperature probe at the intake fan and exhaust vent of the power supply.

Results from Silverstone Strider ST75F COLD load tests
+3.3V +5V +12V1&2 +12V3 +12V4 Watts Efficiency PF Intake Exhaust
Simulated system load tests
2A 5A 4A 2A 2A 145.4W 77% .99 23°C 28°C
3.31V 5.08V 12.24V 12.26V 12.26V
5A 10A 8A 4A 4A 278.4W 81% .99 24°C 30°C
3.28V 5.03V 12.25V 12.27V 12.27V
7A 14A 12A 6A 6A 401.7W 81% .99 24°C 31°C
3.25V 4.98V 12.22V 12.27V 12.25V
10A 17A 16A 8A 8A 522.4W 80% .99 24°C 32°C
3.22V 4.94V 12.18V 12.23V 12.22V
12A 20A 20A 10A 10A 638.8W 79% .99 24°C 35°C
3.19V 4.91V 12.13V 12.21V 12.20V
8A 15A 28A 13A 13A 761.9W 76% .99 25°C 38°C
3.20V 4.99V 11.90V 12.00V 11.98V
3A 4A 28A 13A 13A 683.6W 78% .99 25°C 37°C
3.24V 5.15V 11.76V 11.88V 11.86V

Going from test 1 to 5, we see excellent voltage regulation.  During test 6, we see things break down a bit, but this can be for multiple reasons.  One of which being that we're actually a tad over spec at 761.9W.  The other is that resistance building up in the wire leads and modular connections of the power supply are causing voltages to drop.

To give you an idea of how much the SilverStone ST75F didn't like being loaded up to 761.9W, I shot this video.  You'll note how the voltage readings of each rail seem to bounce around considerably.

In retrospect, check out this video of the ST75F during test 7.  Only the 3.3V and 5V rails have been reduced from the previous test.  The 12V rails are still juiced up putting out 648W of power, yet the bounce in the voltage has been reduced significantly.  In fact, it's almost non-existent.  This tells us the problem we had seen in the video for test 6 is not likely caused by the voltage output rectifiers, because otherwise the bounce would be present regardless of the total power output of the PSU and consistant with the actual load on each rail.

Efficiency is pretty decent, but nothing really special now that we're seeing more and more power supplies that are consistantly over 80% efficient.  Only when the PSU was around 50% loaded did it give me efficiency over 80%.

The fan was very quiet and could barely be heard over the fan of the load tester.

Now were going to run the "hot" load tests. To perform the "hot load tests" I put a side panel on the case the PSU is mounted in and run a hose and an 80MM intake fan into the TAC CPU duct. The heat generated by the load tester is pumped into the other end of the hose.

Results from Silverstone Strider ST75F HOT load tests
+3.3V +5V +12V1&2 +12V3 +12V4 Watts Efficiency PF Intake Exhaust
Simulated system load tests
2A 5A 4A 2A 2A 145.4W 77% .99 38°C 40°C
3.31V 5.08V 12.24V 12.26V 12.26V
5A 10A 8A 4A 4A 278.4W 81% .99 42°C 45°C
3.28V 5.03V 12.25V 12.27V 12.27V
7A 14A 12A 6A 6A 401.7W 81% .99 42°C 47°C
3.25V 4.98V 12.22V 12.27V 12.25V
10A 17A 16A 8A 8A 522.4W 78% .99 43°C 49°C
3.22V 4.94V 12.18V 12.23V 12.22V
12A 20A 20A 10A 10A 638.8W 76% .99 42°C 50°C
3.19V 4.91V 12.13V 12.21V 12.20V
8A 15A 28A 13A 13A 761.9W 73% .99 40°C 52°C
3.20V 4.99V 11.90V 12.00V 11.98V
3A 4A 28A 13A 13A 683.6W 75% .99 40°C 52°C
3.24V 5.15V 11.76V 11.88V 11.86V

The voltages seem to be unaffected by the high temperatures.  The fan did kick into high speed during test 5 and then to an even higher speed again during test 6, which explains the drop in intake temperature during those tests, but the fan was never really "too loud."



( Reviews Main | Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4 | Printer Friendly )



JonnyGURU Feeds
Add our RSS feeds to your favorite RSS Reader or homepage.

JonnyGURU Reviews
AddThis Feed Button

JonnyGURU News
AddThis Feed Button

JonnyGURU Articles
AddThis Feed Button

JonnyGURU Forums
AddThis Feed Button

Follow us onFollow Us!
 
Site-Info | Affiliates | Contact Us | Site-Map
Copyright © 2009 - JonnyGURU.com